Aligning the Three Legs of Carbon Accounting

Session Summary

Important
Quotations

“We’re not doing this for the fun of it. We’re doing this because this is a real thing, a real problem that we need to solve.”
Dr. Karthik Ramanna
“I’d urge companies to stay in the game and to make sure they’re tracking how many moles of CO2 and other things they are emitting as part of their work.”
Dr. M. Sanjayan
“This is one of those issues, carbon accounting, that the more layers you peel back, the more layers you find… It’s become part of, really, our global infrastructure.”
Kathryn Clay
“In order to really incentivize climate action, we need some kind of common rules that really drive climate action in the field.”
Alex Saer

Key
Takeaways

  • Carbon accounting exists to measure the emissions built into every product and service so companies can redesign products, suppliers, and logistics, but tensions arise when companies want to be seen doing something at the lowest cost and when governments use carbon accounting to pursue goals like reindustrialization or restricting imports. 
  • Carbon credit programs like Cercarbono must satisfy several overlapping frameworks at once, including CORSIA for aviation, the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market, and national systems such as the carbon taxes in Colombia and Chile and the emissions trading systems in California and Europe, which takes time that climate action doesn’t have. 
  • Sanjayan argued the problem is cultural rather than technical, describing companies as “snowflakes” unwinding commitments at the first criticism, scientists as “purists” demanding impractical perfection, and governments as “ostriches” that created carbon markets and then left the guardrails to NGOs. 
  • He also pointed to a double standard on risk, since investors keep funding founders of failed companies yet shy away from a young sector like carbon markets, especially in places like Colombia. 
  • Ramanna compared the 2022–23 Guardian reporting that many offsets lacked real substance to the 1929 crash, which led to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), and framed the current moment as a chance for “disruptive renewal.” 
  • Smart CEOs treat carbon accounting as business strategy regardless of politics, since a changing climate will change customer behavior, and a shared accounting system rewards the companies that invest in innovation now. 
  • The panel’s proposed next steps were convergence of carbon market frameworks, companies staying committed to tracking their emissions, and a U.S. emissions accounting board, which Ramanna called a bipartisan opportunity because the U.S. has some of the world’s cleanest production. 

Action
Items

  • Governments, standard-setters, and bodies like CORSIA and the Integrity Council should work toward common rules across both voluntary and compliance carbon markets. 
  • The U.S. government should consider creating an emissions accounting board within the Department of Commerce or Energy, modeled on the role the SEC and GAAP played for capital markets. 
  • Companies should keep their climate commitments and continue measuring product-level emissions, even if they can’t yet address their full footprint. 
  • Governments should provide clear guardrails and invest at scale in carbon markets to create the certainty needed to attract private capital. 
  • Scientists and standard-setters should prioritize practical, workable standards over perfect but impractical ones. 
  • Investors should reassess their appetite for well-run carbon projects in the Global South rather than avoiding the sector because of past failures.